
Music / Art Song Canberra presents Lotte Betts-Dean and Ronan Apcar, Wesley Music Centre. November 15. Reviewed by DAVID WHITBREAD
Superlatives fail. This is quite possibly the best voice and piano recital I have heard.
How to convey to you what was so special about this moment in time?
Expectations. A program of 24 items. An announcement that three had been cut for technical reasons (electronica). So, 21 left. No overarching title. Ugh. But on inspection, quite an intriguing melange of genres and composers, dead and alive, male and female.
The pianist. Ronan Apcar studied performance and composition at the ANU School of Music. During and since, he has carved out an eclectic career involving solo piano and collaborative performances, often involving composing or arranging.

Today, his performance was simply phenomenal. He urged colours and sounds from a single piano, from the most tender to the most strident, from keyboard to strumming the strings, using it percussively and, frankly, orchestrally.
From the first moments of Bartok’s Fekete Tod, he commanded attention and created a sound space to support the soloist. His playing was, at times intense, always sensitive, crisply rhythmic, always historically informed. He employs a simply huge dynamic range, making a single piano a symphony.
In Lili Boulanger’s Parfois, Je Suis Triste, the shimmering piano and its magical mix with the vocal solo became almost too beautiful, but set the air humming.
The singer. Lotte Betts-Dean is an Australian citizen of the world in high demand. Her repertoire choices are as eclectic as Ronan’s – and she performs across genres, from early music to the most contemporary.
From the first moments of the Bartok, she demonstrated a stunning rich tone. Smoky, silky, smooth as the best mezzo-sopranos. But agile and versatile. All the while maintaining that dark chocolaty tone.
Her immaculate pitching across a truly impressive vocal range was so accurate that, when the piano sustain pedal was on, it captured the notes she was singing and kept them ringing in the Wesley acoustic.
Lotte’s diction is excellent in English. But today she convinced in many languages and accents, including casual English, French, German, Italian, Hungarian.
In Charli xcx and AG Cook’s I Think About It All the Time from 2024, she sang at an incredible speed. But it felt almost like intruding on someone’s inner dialogue to listen to this song. Wonderful nevertheless.
She also effectively employs vocalising techniques from various folk traditions. In Giacinto Scelsi’s unaccompanied Hô 1, she sustained a bell-like note using her body and mouth as resonance chambers and rhythmically punctuated it with other sounds. Later, Erin Gee’s Mouthpiece 1 employed a huge variety of birdsong, whistling, popping, whispers and child sounds.
This was only this program’s third iteration. The difference this time: Ronan was effectively recreating an electronic experience acoustically.
It spans centuries. From composers like Monteverdi and Barbara Strozzi from the 1600s, Clara Schumann in the 1800s, to Messiaen, Ligeti, Shoenberg, Björk, John Adams and Sinéad O’Connor in the 20th century, to a moving finale blending William Bolcom’s Waitin’ with Blossom Dearie’s lush Touch the Hand of Love.
And the glorious encore Faure’s Après un Rêve. ‘After a dream’, indeed…
The whole was performed as a single work, with no applause throughout by request. This is advanced storytelling. Each song transitioned artfully with singer and/or pianist changing direction, genre and mood. This juxtaposition of works and their chronology made even the most familiar fresh.
Both performers are clearly at the top of their respective games. Yet the confluence is where the magic happens. Their concentration and listening skills capture and build on each other’s interpretative nuance. What a collaboration.
Art Song Canberra is the ‘last one standing’ and celebrated 50 years this year – most similar Australian societies folded years ago. Art song (or ‘lieder’) is an equal pairing of voice and piano, music and words. Demonstrated perfectly today. And still relevant.
So is this the future? I sure hope so.
News all day, every day at CityNewsQBN.com.au.
Leave a Reply