News location:

Tuesday, November 17, 2026 | Digital Edition | Crossword & Sudoku

Aged-care horror system needs urgent overhaul

Hospitals have a vested interest in moving patients through their system to free scarce beds of what are commonly known as “bed blockers” – long-term patients with mild acute symptoms but high chronic care needs. Photo: Pexels

“People will continue to miss out on needed care at the most vulnerable point of their adult lives. Inevitably, some will suffer serious consequences, including – it needs to be said out loud – neglect, suffering and death,” warns political columnist ROBERT McMAHON.

When Labor came to power in 2022, it moved quickly to establish a Royal Commission into the Robodebt scheme, an automated process in which some Centrelink recipients’ incomes were averaged, through computer modelling, into an assumed debt.

Dr Robert McMahon.

Yet, as the Royal Commission found, in a significant number of instances, the averaging had miscalculated liabilities, with the result that many Centrelink beneficiaries were not actually indebted, or not to the extent the modelling indicated.

The unhappy result was that Robodebt ruined many lives. It was a scheme poorly conceived and even more poorly implemented. One that gave too much weight to computer modelling and too little to human judgment. And one that valued volume over quality.

Despite this recent disgrace, the federal government – right now – is replicating the worst drivers of Robodebt in the aged-care sector, through the automated new decision-making apparatus of the Aged Care Assessment Teams (ACAT).

ACAT is the process by which older Australians are assessed for aged-care eligibility according to a complex matrix of need and urgency. It is the so-called gateway to residential aged care (commonly known as nursing homes) and home care, now delivered through Support at Home and the lower-level Commonwealth Home Support Program.

As part of reforms adopted in 2025 by the Albanese government to improve administration of the aged-care sector, automated assessment using algorithms was introduced into ACAT evaluations. These replaced assessment by human assessors expert in the aged-care sector and familiar with the realities of elderly people’s living needs.

While assessment meetings are still conducted by humans, many skilled and empathetic to the needs of the clients, these are no longer assessments but information-gathering interviews.

Fed into the assessment tool, the algorithm-based evaluations draw upon words and expressions from records and inputs about the person to produce an assessed care need at assigned urgency.

Where current care providers, such as hospitals, have a vested interest in moving patients through their system to free scarce beds of what are commonly known as “bed blockers” – long-term patients with mild acute symptoms but high chronic care needs – particular risks can arise. Institutional clinical assessments, usually not readily available to the patient, can present an overly rosy picture of a patient’s capacity.

The ACAT algorithm sucks up this frequently voluminous clinical material, drawing on particular words and phrases programmed to indicate need and urgency – or the documented absence of it.

Set against a patient’s or carer’s inexpert or unskilled advocacy of their own circumstances, the algorithm can give primacy to the “official” institutional assessment, despite the obvious vested interest in hospitals wanting patients discharged as quickly as possible.

In these circumstances, the health and aged-care system shifts risk and responsibility from itself on to patients/clients and their families. Economists have a term for this outsourcing of risk: moral hazard. And it is plainly a feature of the newly automated ACAT system.

The result of the new automated ACAT process is an aged-care “gateway” that is opaque, confusing and not a little dystopian.

A gateway made difficult to enter and whose passage is granted subject to the graces of an algorithm prone to producing inconsistent assessments.

Resultant assessments frequently under-estimate a client’s needs and over-estimate capacity to self-source their satisfaction.

Even after approval, depending on assessed urgency, funded packages can take sometimes up to a year or more to become available.

Such has been the community outcry over the perverse and unrealistic assessments generated by the automated ACAT process that the government recently announced a review to commence next year – making any change unlikely for at least another year or more.

Older Australians and their families deserve better than this. 

Until the ACAT assessment system is reformed, people will continue to miss out on needed care at the most vulnerable point of their adult lives. Inevitably, some will suffer serious consequences, including – it needs to be said out loud – neglect, suffering and death. Known now, this is entirely intolerable and demands more urgent action than yet another review.

Labor stridently pursued the former government over its mishandling of Robodebt. It needs now to confront the uncomfortable reality that it has its own Robodebt-like scandal on its hands – of its own hand.

Rather than replicate the mistakes made by the former government in stubbornly repelling responsibility, the Albanese government should act decisively to overhaul ACAT. And now.

A longer version of this column was originally published in The Mandarin.

Dr Robert McMahon is a visiting fellow at the Australian National University, adjunct professor of government at the University of Canberra, and a former assistant secretary of the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet.

News all day, every day at CityNewsQBN.com.au.

Share this

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

*

Related Posts

Planning

Labor’s ‘we-know-best’ ethos is wearing thin

"While it developed effective energy and stamp duty policies, ACT Labor’s overall response has been hindered by superficial analysis, partly stemming from the absence of an opposition to hold it to account," writes columnist MIKE QUIRK. 

Follow us on Instagram @canberracitynews