
“The system allowed physical changes in road conditions to be masked or altered in reporting simply by changing the system settings, and the government shamelessly used that tool,” write JON STANHOPE & KHALID AHMED.
These days, referring to an Auditor-General’s performance audit of an ACT Government program as “damning” has become cliched.
However, the latest audit report on road maintenance is certainly damning of the City and Environment Directorate.
In fact, given the implications of some of the findings, that criticism would also extend to central agencies (principally Treasury), which are supposedly responsible for the accountability of line agencies.
The full report of the audit (No. 9 of 2026) can be accessed at the ACT Audit Office’s website.
The comprehensive audit spans 129 pages and covers a range of matters including: the asset maintenance strategy, strategic and operational planning, delivery of resurfacing program, procurement, financial performance and internal and public performance reporting.
The objective of the audit was “to assess whether the ACT public road network is being effectively maintained”.
It is important to note that the Auditor-General’s remit does not encompass assessing or reviewing government policy, which is the purview of the Legislative Assembly and its committee processes. Performance audits typically assess how a stated policy has been implemented or a program managed.
In this instance, according to the report, the audit “considered the activities of the City and Environment Directorate (formerly the Transport Canberra and City Services Directorate) to plan for, and implement, programs for the maintenance of the ACT public road network surface”.
The starting position for the audit was the Roads ACT Strategic Asset Management Plan (2018) that was developed to provide strategies for maintaining, rehabilitating, renewing and growing the relevant assets – ie, roads.
Governance arrangements were ineffective
The audit found that the three-year plan for the period 2018 to 2021 has not been updated since it was first developed.
It also found: “Governance arrangements for the management of the Plan (and other strategic asset management plans) in the former Transport Canberra and City Services Directorate were ineffective.
“Annual reviews of the Plan did not occur and a biennial review of the Strategic Asset Management Framework in November 2022 by the former TCCS Executive Board was cursory.”
The neglect of the 2018 Plan and failure to establish any meaningful governance to implement or review it, in our opinion, can be viewed in the context of the effort and resources being directed towards stage 1 of the tram project.
The government came up with a new plan in 2023, the Strategic Road Maintenance and Renewal Program. Key elements of the program were announced by the Minister for Transport and City Services – Chris Steel at that time – to the Legislative Assembly in February 2023, as well as through media releases in December 2022 and September 2023 as follows:
- A 52 per cent increase in expenditure on road maintenance.
- A continued primary focus on preventative bituminous resealing and a 150 per cent increase in asphalting; and
- Overall growth of total resurfacing meterage, from 1 million to 1.268 million sqm.
The strategy was aimed at addressing a known problem, according to the audit report, that the Territory’s road surfaces and pavement structure was deteriorating at a faster rate than was offset by the maintenance and rehabilitation levels at that time.
These elements were finalised into a 68-page strategy document in September 2024 following several cabinet considerations.
In other jurisdictions, these documents are publicly available, but not in the ACT – in other words, it has remained a state secret. It gets worse.
Central to road maintenance is the Pavement Condition Index (PCI) in the Pavement Management System. Reports from this system specify road condition settings, model the effects of budgets and changes in the condition index and produce specific work programs.
The audit revealed that it is possible to create a change in the Pavement Condition Index score by changing system settings rather than changes in the data that are reflective of physical changes to the road surface condition.

The audit reviewed the reports from 2018 to 2024 and found that weightings for conditions such as cracking, roughness and skid were changed in the system between 2018 and 2020 and again in 2021.
In other words, the system allowed physical changes in road conditions to be masked or altered in reporting simply by changing the system settings, and the government shamelessly used that tool.
Here is what the Audit Office had to say about this issue: “Because the Pavement Condition Index is a function of both changes in the condition of the road network and changes to system settings it is imperative that Roads ACT be publicly transparent and explicit with respect to: levels of service and experience that road users can expect; and any changes to system settings (including changes to weightings for the five condition parameters that comprise the score) that may affect the calculation of the Pavement Condition Index.”
No strategic or accountability indicator
The Pavement Condition Index of Territorial Roads is a strategic performance indicator in the budget papers and subject to mandatory reporting under legislation.
That was until the 2026-27 Budget, when it was quietly dropped. The audit has pointed out, concerningly, that this means that there is no strategic or accountability indicator related to the condition of roads or the road network in the ACT.
Changes to performance indicators and measures could not be made without the agreement of Treasury and ultimately Chris Steel, as Treasurer and indeed perhaps the whole of the cabinet.
We will not speculate on the catalyst for dropping this performance indicator in this instance, but note that this is not the first time this has occurred.
An indicator critical in hospital patient flow management was similarly dropped around the time the ACT Government relegated health care to a lower priority than the light rail project.
Readers can only guess how the government has performed in delivering on the touted objectives of the strategy from the above clues or perhaps looking at some of the municipal roads resealed just a few months ago but now in need of mowing!
Asphalting, although relatively costlier than bituminous resealing, adds structural strength, has longer life and provides a smoother and quieter ride.
The audit found that in 2024-25, expenditure on bituminous resealing was 68 per cent higher and that on asphalting was 44 per cent lower than the business case proposal.
Interestingly actual expenditure was 12 per cent below budget. Clearly, road maintenance in the ACT has not moved to a better, more sustainable regime.
The audit made 14 recommendations, which we have been unable to cover due to space considerations. Each of the recommendations is damning in its context, essentially asking the directorate to just do its job.
Relevant legislation requires the Auditor-General to ask the agency for comment on its report at the draft stage and publish it in the final report. The directorate’s response was a sheepish or perhaps more realistically a dismissive, embarrassed silence.
Jon Stanhope is a former chief minister of the ACT and Dr Khalid Ahmed a former senior ACT Treasury official.
News all day, every day at CityNewsQBN.com.au.
Leave a Reply