News location:

Friday, November 20, 2026 | Digital Edition | Crossword & Sudoku

It maybe wine time, but why?

American author Barbara Scott-Goodman… “Almost all food goes well with wine.”

“In my columns, I always try to say why I did or did not like the taste of a particular wine or why it does or doesn’t match with the food I’m eating,” writes wine columnist RICHARD CALVER.

It was, with disappointment, that I finished a library book entitled Wine Time, about “wine with bites”.

Richard Calver.

This was not some Dracula spin, but a book that announced 70 recipes for simple food “bites” that “pair perfectly” with wine.

The author, Barbara Scott-Goodman lives and works in New York. She indicates her philosophy about wine and food matching in the book’s introduction: “Almost all food goes well with wine. Even though there are so-called rules about pairing certain wines with certain foods, feel free to throw these out the window.

“What matters most is that you enjoy the wine you buy and drink. I recommend that you let your palate be your guide. Use my pairing suggestions as starting points and then try a lot of different wines with various foods until you figure out what you like.”

Fair enough. That advice about drinking what you like is, I believe, sound. But my disappointment arises because in the specific, very short wine advice that accompanies each recipe, the author doesn’t tell us why she thinks the wines match the chosen food. There’s an absence of explanation about why she chose the particular wine and what aspects of that choice enhanced either the flavour of the food or the taste of the wine.

It seems that she has ignored an explanation for her take on why the wine she points to matches with her recipes. Why did she start with the wine choice she proposes?

In my columns, I always try to say why I did or did not like the taste of a particular wine or why it does or doesn’t match with the food I’m eating.

But, for example, with the recipe for pork and ricotta meatballs, which sound very tasty, the advice is: “Chianti Classico and full-bodied Zinfandel always complement red meat, and either one would be a good choice to serve here.”

The cover of Wine Time.

Now pork is not red meat. I agree that a full-bodied red wine, not necessarily Zinfandel, goes well with red meat. Zinfandel, largely derived from California, ranges in style from white, rose and a light red to a deeply coloured high-alcohol wine.

But the pairing of a red wine of depth with red meat is a culinary classic. The tannins in the red wine bind to the proteins and fats in the meat, creating a less astringent wine that usually complements the richness of the meat.

Plus the acidity in the wine acts as a counterbalance to the meat’s richness, preventing the flavours of either from becoming overwhelming. This balance allows for a more complex and satisfying taste experience.

But with pork-based dishes, I tend to want to drink an oaky, buttery chardonnay. Pork usually has a much milder flavour than red meat so, especially in this case with ricotta, which adds a creaminess to the recipe, I would want an oaked chardonnay because it should have a rich and creamy texture that melds well with the lighter meatiness of pork.

I’ve just described why I like the way that pork dishes go with oaked chardonnay. I think it wouldn’t have stretched Ms Scott-Goodman to do the same: provide an explanation as to why you liked the wine and the way you believe it matches with your recipes.

Perhaps I was expecting too much. After all, the book is called Wine Time, not Wine Insights. On the evidence, though, it certainly left me hungry for explanations.

News all day, every day at CityNewsQBN.com.au.

Richard Calver

Richard Calver

Share this

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

*

Related Posts

Personal finance

Taxing business of Christmas parties

Christmas parties might be a time to celebrate, but for employers they can bring unexpected tax complications. Chartered accountant GAIL FREEMAN explains the liabilities of fringe benefits tax, staff entertainment and gifts.

Follow us on Instagram @canberracitynews